Wednesday, June 5, 2013

A motion so nice, they passed it twice!

Detail Update: Rescission of ayres Honor:

On June 4, 2013 the San Mateo County Board of Supervisors acted unanimously on a motion put forward by Supervisor Dave Pine to rescind a 2002 County Honor for his "lifetime of achievement" in "psychiatry" for his "tireless efforts to improve the lives of children and adolescents."

There were at least 10 people present to witness the vote as supporters of the victims. Several of these people spoke.

I was present at the meeting, and in this post I'll give you my observations, along with links to some clips of the video.

First, I have to say: some newspapers (The Mercury News)  have repeatedly referred to this as a "small, symbolic" move, and indeed quote Supervisor Pine as having called it "largely symbolic." I'd like to say that this was no "small" event, and while Pine may have referred to it as a symbolic motion from a government procedural perspective, it was very clear from his presentation that Pine understood that from a human and emotional point of view, the symbolism was no "small" matter. I'll have more to say on this shortly.

The San Mateo Daily Journal has an excellent article (pdf) AND editorial statement (pdf) on the matter this morning. (I will point out though, that the paper keeps running the photo of ayres that makes it look as though he's a beleaguered  prisoner - I don't know if it's for sympathy or sensationalism - but ayres looks nothing like this, and hasn't for some time. he's of healthy weight and well groomed. he certainly isn't dressed in prison garb.)

For future reference, the Board's Agenda page will post a link to a YouTube video copy, and there is already Real Media streaming video available (Look at the items available for the June 4, 2013 meeting.) But I have broken segments out of the streaming media and loaded them to YouTube to make viewing easier, since the official YouTube stream is not yet available as of this posting.

Supervisor Dave Pine's presentation of the motion:
The first video clip includes Pine's introduction of the motion. His words demonstrate that he clearly understands the weight that the whole ayres matter has had on the victims and their families and friends. He clearly has felt the extent and weight of impact, and his emotional presentation and comments provide depth and an imperative punch to this "symbolic" matter. I can't thank Pine enough.

For victims of ayres: I highly recommend you watch Pine's presentation. Be prepared for roiling emotions as you watch. There are not words to express the experience adequately.

Notice that Pine does not refer to the felon as "Doctor" at any point in time. Pine is clear and strong in his understanding of the matter.

Also included in this video, Board President Don Horsley reads from a letter from the parent of a victim, and is clearly moved by the statements.

Victoria Balfour: 
Balfour came from New York to witness the rescission of the honor. She put some perspective on how difficult it is to bring justice in this kind of crime -- the problem of getting victims to want to take the risk of the embarrassment and  exposure of speaking out about the crimes in order to begin the legal process -- the difficulties encountered in dealing with the professional shield that ayres has built over years of political connections within the community, etc... She provided a great background on the case, providing the opening bookend on a very difficult journey.

Jonathan Huddleston:
Jonathan spoke to provide some perspective from family/friend point of view -- to put a face on the victims. He spoke about a close friend of his who was molested by ayres as a young boy, and the struggles he experienced through life, including significant effort to bring his life back together. Ultimately the darkness won, and Huddleston's friend committed suicide. His friend's 50th birthday would have been on August 6, the day ayres is (currently) scheduled to be sentenced. I very much appreciated his message, but if you are a victim, and in a dark place right now, I'd recommend coming back to this video when you are in a better place -- Huddleston's intent was to provide a vignette of the human experience of being a victim, and he did a fantastic job.

Jon Buckheit:
Buckheit has been interested in the ayres matter from a victim's advocate perspective, having dealt with San Mateo County prosecution previously. His statement provides the closing bookend to Balfour's statement in emphasizing the difficulty of dealing with inspiring authorities to pursue the prosecution of well connected individuals within the county who are accused of crimes. His comments were succinct and powerful.

You may notice that before Buckheit speaks, another man was leaving the podium. I have not included a clip of that man's comments; he was very passionate about a cause that was important to him linked to psychiatric care, and he used the rescission item to speak further about his cause, but it was not relevant to the issue.

Also, at the end of Buckheit's talk, you'll notice that the Board didn't remember completing the vote after the motion was read, and voted again on the motion.

At any rate, all of the people who spoke brought great value to the table and the symbolic passage of the motion was no small matter.

william hamilton ayres was arrested on April 5, 2007 on charges relating to his molestation of many young boys while he was alleging to provide psychiatric care to private patients as well as referrals for evaluation from the juvenile court system in San Mateo County. ayres has been delaying his way through the system free from custody until this latest gambit to skirt prosecution by playing demented for the courts. ayres is currently under the conservatorship of his daughter Barbara Ayres of Sacramento, CA. ayres was found GUILTY of the the child molestation charges against him on May 16, 2013, and is yet again left free on bail while we await sentencing. 

ayres has had significant interaction over the years with local politicians on boards like the "Children and Families First Commission,"  including the DA who was serving when prosecution began Jim Fox and Assemblyman Rich Gordon. In fact, Gordon nominated ayres for a lifetime achievement award for his "Tireless effort to improve the lives of children." This honor was rescinded in a motion put forward by Supervisor Dave Pine on June 4, 2013. ayres has also been vocally supported during his criminal trial by local head-shrinkers like Bart BlinderEtta BryantMel BlausteinHarry CorenTom CieslaRobert KimmichLarry LurieMaria LymberisRichard ShadoanCaptane Thomson, and Harold Wallach.


  1. Hey, Deep :

    Any word from Marta Diaz or Etta Bryant?

  2. I am eager to hear what those two weasels have to say about Ayres's plea. You think they still believe that the dozens of ex-patients who accused him are fabricators and liars?

  3. Marta Diaz is the prosecutor in 1993 who told the attorney for a victim that Ayres "could not possibly have molested the boy."

    Then, she continued to send boys to Ayres as a prosecutor. And when she became a juvenile judge, she sent MANY boys to Ayres. And in 2002, when the police started to investigate a victim's claim, Diaz actively tried to get the police to stop investigating Ayres, because, she said, "Ayres and I are friends."

    Then she continued to send boys to him for another 15 months.

    Why is this sick puppy still a judge?

    And let's not forget Margaret Kemp, who was sending boys to Ayres as recently as 2001.

    1. Poor judge of character, more like.

  4. Nice to see that Ohio has ethical District Attorneys. This DA fired a prosecutor for posing as the former girlfriend of an alleged murderer whose case he was prosecuting.

    If the prosecutor had pulled this stunt in San Mateo County, District Attorney Steve Wagstaffe would have promoted him:

    "Prosecutor Fired After Posing as Alleged Killer's Girlfriend on Facebook"

    A Cuyahoga County prosecutor was fired after admitting he posed as an accused killer's ex-girlfriend on Facebook to persuade witnesses to change their testimony.

    Former Assistant County Prosecutor Aaron Brockler said he did nothing wrong, according to the Cleveland Plain Dealer.

    "Law enforcement, including prosecutors, have long engaged in the practice of using a ruse to obtain the truth," Brockler, 35, a county prosecutor since 2006, told the Plain Dealer. "I think the public is better off for what I did."

    County Prosecutor Timothy J. McGinty disagreed. "This office does not condone and will not tolerate such unethical behavior," McGinty said. "He disgraced this office and everyone who works here."

  5. Los Angeles Times

    April 5, 2013: "State Bar Says Del Norte County DA Should Be Disbarred"

    SAN FRANCISCO -- A California bar court has recommended that Del Norte County Dist. Atty. Jon Michael Alexander be stripped of his law license for prosecutorial misconduct.

    In an opinion released Friday, the State Bar Court of California found Alexander guilty of withholding exculpatory evidence, perjury and speaking to a defendant without the permission of her attorney.